Skip to main content
6 minutes

NMPA and NSAI Push to Subpoena MLC Documents in Phonorecords V Rate Fight

Architectural blueprint of a multi-story building with balconies and a flat roof, on a dark blue grid background.

The NMPA and NSAI are pushing to subpoena MLC documents to use as evidence in the Phonorecords V rate-setting case, targeting Spotify's bundle accounting practices. Bundle accounting determines how revenue is allocated between music and other services, directly affecting the mechanical royalty pool available to songwriters. According to UniteSync, we have collected €1.4M in royalties for 1K+ music creators across 117 territories.

The National Music Publishers' Association and the Nashville Songwriters Association International filed a renewed motion to subpoena the Mechanical Licensing Collective for documents related to its ongoing dispute with Spotify. The subpoena targets bundle-related materials that the NMPA and NSAI believe are relevant to the Phonorecords V rate-setting proceeding. This legal maneuver reveals how streaming bundle accounting practices remain a central battleground in determining what songwriters get paid.

The Phonorecords V Context

Phonorecords V is the Copyright Royalty Board proceeding that will set mechanical royalty rates for 2028-2032. The rates determined in this case will govern how much streaming services pay songwriters for mechanical rights. Previous Phonorecords proceedings established the current headline rate of 15.1% of revenue for paid subscription services. The NMPA wants higher rates. Streaming services want lower rates or different calculation methods.

Bundle accounting sits at the center of this dispute. When Spotify bundles music streaming with audiobooks or other services, how should revenue be allocated between those offerings? The answer directly affects the royalty pool. If Spotify can attribute more revenue to audiobooks and less to music, mechanical royalties shrink proportionally.

The MLC sued Spotify earlier this year over bundle accounting practices. That lawsuit alleged Spotify was improperly reducing its royalty payments by reclassifying subscribers. The NMPA and NSAI now want discovery materials from that case to use as evidence in Phonorecords V.

Why the Subpoena Matters

Free Audit

Curious about how much money your music has made in royalties?

Estimate Now

The subpoena request suggests the NMPA believes MLC internal documents will reveal problematic bundle accounting practices. If those documents show Spotify systematically underpaying mechanical royalties through bundle manipulation, that evidence could strengthen arguments for higher statutory rates or stricter bundle accounting rules in Phonorecords V.

This is the second attempt to subpoena these materials. The first request apparently met resistance. The renewed motion indicates the NMPA and NSAI consider this evidence critical enough to fight for it twice.

The timing matters. Phonorecords V proceedings are active now. Rate-setting cases involve extensive economic testimony and modeling. Hard evidence of underpayment through bundle accounting could shift how Copyright Royalty Judges evaluate competing rate proposals.

What This Means for Independent Songwriters

Bundle accounting affects every songwriter with music on streaming platforms. When services bundle music with other products, the revenue allocation method determines your mechanical royalty base. A songwriter earning mechanical royalties on 1 million streams per month might see different payments depending on whether those streams came from standalone music subscribers or bundle subscribers.

Consider a simplified example. A standalone Spotify Premium subscriber pays $10.99 monthly. Under current rates, roughly $1.66 goes to mechanical royalties (15.1% of revenue). But if that same subscriber is reclassified as a bundle subscriber and Spotify allocates only $6 of the subscription fee to music, mechanical royalties drop to roughly $0.91. That is a 45% reduction per subscriber.

Multiply that across millions of subscribers and the numbers become material. If bundle accounting practices reduce the effective royalty base by even 10%, a songwriter earning $10,000 annually in mechanical royalties loses $1,000. A songwriter earning $100,000 loses $10,000.

The Phonorecords V outcome will either codify current bundle accounting methods, restrict them, or potentially expand them. Independent songwriters should understand that this rate-setting case is not just about percentage points. It is about the denominator in the royalty calculation. A higher rate applied to a smaller base can yield less money than a lower rate applied to a larger base.

You cannot directly influence Copyright Royalty Board proceedings as an individual songwriter. But you can ensure you are collecting all royalties owed under current rules. Many independent songwriters leave money unclaimed at the MLC, at foreign societies, and in DSP black box pools. Recovering those royalties provides a buffer against potential rate changes.

How UniteSync Fits In

UniteSync operates in the gap between what streaming services report and what songwriters actually collect. We have recovered over $547K in previously unclaimed mechanical and performance royalties for independent songwriters and small publishers. That money was owed under existing rates but went uncollected due to registration gaps, metadata mismatches, and administrative complexity.

Bundle accounting disputes like the MLC v. Spotify case highlight how complicated streaming royalty calculations have become. When services change subscriber classifications or revenue allocation methods, royalty statements become harder to audit. Many independent songwriters lack the resources to verify whether their mechanical royalties reflect accurate bundle accounting.

UniteSync addresses this by systematically checking for unclaimed royalties across the MLC, CMOs, PROs, foreign societies, and DSP black box pools. We handle the registration, matching, and claims process. If bundle accounting practices have caused underpayments that later get corrected, those corrections often sit unclaimed unless someone actively pursues them.

We do not litigate rate-setting cases or challenge streaming service accounting practices. We recover money that is already owed but uncollected. As rate battles intensify and accounting methods grow more complex, ensuring you collect what you are already owed becomes more important, not less.

The Broader Rate-Setting Battle

The NMPA subpoena push is one move in a multi-year rate-setting process. Phonorecords V will involve economic experts, competing rate proposals, and extensive testimony. The Copyright Royalty Board will weigh arguments about market rates, willing buyer/willing seller standards, and policy objectives.

Streaming services will argue that higher rates threaten their business models. Publishers will argue that current rates undervalue songwriting. Independent songwriters sit in the middle, affected by the outcome but largely absent from the negotiating table.

The subpoena fight over MLC documents suggests both sides believe bundle accounting evidence could be decisive. If the NMPA succeeds in obtaining and presenting compelling evidence of underpayment, it could shift rate-setting momentum. If the documents prove less damaging than expected, it could weaken publisher arguments.

Either way, the case reinforces that streaming royalty calculations remain contested territory. Rates are not settled. Accounting methods are not settled. Independent songwriters should treat their streaming royalties as provisional until these disputes resolve.

Reporting via Digital Music News.

Ensure you are collecting all royalties owed under current rates while rate-setting battles continue. Get a free royalty audit from UniteSync to identify unclaimed mechanical and performance royalties across the MLC, PROs, and foreign societies.

Frequently asked questions

What is Phonorecords V?

Phonorecords V is a Copyright Royalty Board proceeding that will set mechanical royalty rates for 2028-2032. These rates determine how much streaming services pay songwriters for the right to reproduce their songs.

How does bundle accounting affect my royalties?

Bundle accounting determines how much revenue streaming services allocate to music versus other services like audiobooks. If more revenue is attributed to non-music services, the mechanical royalty pool shrinks, reducing what songwriters earn per stream.

Why are the NMPA and NSAI seeking MLC documents?

They believe MLC internal documents from the Spotify lawsuit will reveal evidence of improper bundle accounting practices. This evidence could strengthen their arguments for higher statutory rates in Phonorecords V.

Can I influence the Phonorecords V outcome as an independent songwriter?

Individual songwriters cannot directly participate in Copyright Royalty Board proceedings. However, you can ensure you are collecting all royalties owed under current rules and advocate through industry organizations.

What should I do about my streaming royalties while rate battles continue?

Verify that you are collecting all mechanical and performance royalties owed under current rates. Many songwriters leave money unclaimed at the MLC, foreign societies, and DSP black box pools. A royalty audit can identify unclaimed payments.

How does the current 15.1% rate work?

The 15.1% rate means that streaming services allocate 15.1% of their subscription revenue to mechanical royalties for songwriters. This rate applies to paid subscription services and was set in previous Phonorecords proceedings.

What happens if bundle accounting practices are restricted?

If the Copyright Royalty Board restricts how services can allocate revenue between music and other offerings, the mechanical royalty pool could expand, potentially increasing payments to songwriters.

Is this the first time bundle accounting has been disputed?

No. The MLC sued Spotify earlier this year over bundle accounting practices, alleging that Spotify was improperly reducing royalty payments by reclassifying subscribers. The NMPA and NSAI now want to use evidence from that case in Phonorecords V.

AUTHOR

Charly

CEO & Co-founder, UniteSync

Carlos Palop is a seasoned music publishing expert, adept in rights management and royalty distribution, ensuring artists' works are protected and profitably managed. Their strategic expertise and commitment to fair practices have made them a trusted figure in the industry.