Carlos PalopEU Advocate General Weighs In on Belgium's Artist Remuneration Right Implementation

The Court of Justice of the European Union's advocate general Maciej Szpunar has published an opinion on Belgium's implementation of the EU Copyright Directive's artist remuneration provisions. The case examines whether Belgium correctly transposed Article 18 of the directive, which guarantees performers and authors appropriate and proportionate remuneration from exploitation of their works. While advocate general opinions are not binding, they heavily influence final court rulings and signal how EU copyright law may evolve across member states.
The Belgium Implementation Dispute
Belgium implemented Article 18 by creating a new remuneration right that allows performers to claim payment directly from streaming services and other digital platforms. This approach differs from most EU countries, which rely on existing collective management structures to distribute streaming royalties. The European Commission challenged Belgium's implementation, arguing it goes beyond what the directive requires and creates legal uncertainty for digital services operating across multiple territories.
The core question is whether member states can create new payment mechanisms or must work within existing frameworks. Belgium's law allows performers to bypass traditional intermediaries and negotiate directly with platforms. This matters because streaming services already pay mechanical and performance royalties through established channels. Adding a parallel payment obligation could mean platforms pay twice for the same usage, or it could mean performers gain leverage they currently lack.
What This Means for Independent Songwriters
If the court upholds Belgium's approach, other EU countries may follow with similar direct remuneration rights. For independent songwriters, this creates both opportunity and complexity. On one hand, direct payment rights could mean faster access to streaming royalties without waiting for collective management organizations to process and distribute funds. On the other hand, it fragments an already complicated royalty system.
Consider a practical example. An independent songwriter in Belgium currently receives streaming royalties through their PRO for performance rights and through their publisher or administrator for mechanical rights. If Belgium's law stands, they might also claim a separate remuneration right payment directly from Spotify or Apple Music. That sounds beneficial until you realize it means tracking three separate payment streams, each with different reporting standards and payment schedules.
The bigger risk is underpayment through fragmentation. When royalties flow through multiple channels, money falls through cracks. Black box royalties accumulate when systems cannot match payments to rightsholders. Adding a third payment channel increases the surface area for errors. Independent songwriters without dedicated royalty tracking often miss payments simply because they do not know to look in every possible place.
For songwriters outside Belgium, the opinion matters because it sets precedent. If the court rules that member states have broad discretion to implement remuneration rights, expect a patchwork of national laws across the EU. A songwriter with streams in ten EU countries could face ten different payment mechanisms. That makes comprehensive royalty recovery nearly impossible without specialized help.
How UniteSync Fits In
This case illustrates exactly why independent songwriters need centralized royalty recovery. As payment channels multiply and national implementations diverge, tracking every potential revenue source becomes a full-time job. UniteSync exists to solve this problem by monitoring all mechanical and performance royalty sources across territories, including emerging payment rights like Belgium's.
UniteSync has recovered over $547K in previously unclaimed royalties for independent artists precisely because we track the fragmented landscape this case represents. When a new payment channel opens or a country implements a novel interpretation of EU law, independent songwriters rarely hear about it until years later. By then, royalties have accumulated in black boxes or been redistributed to other parties.
Our approach covers the Mechanical Licensing Collective, collection management organizations, performing rights organizations, foreign societies, and digital service provider black box funds. If Belgium's direct remuneration right becomes standard across the EU, UniteSync will track those payments too. The more complex the system becomes, the more critical comprehensive monitoring becomes.
Practical Implications
Independent songwriters should watch for three developments. First, the final court ruling will likely arrive within six months of this opinion. Second, if Belgium wins, expect other countries to propose similar laws within the next year. Third, platforms may challenge these laws individually in each country, creating years of legal uncertainty.
During this uncertainty, royalties will accumulate in holding accounts. Platforms cannot distribute money when they face conflicting legal obligations. Those funds eventually move to black boxes or get redistributed based on market share, which favors major rightsholders. Independent songwriters lose out unless they actively claim what they are owed.
The advocate general's opinion also highlights a broader trend: EU copyright law is fragmenting despite harmonization efforts. Each country interprets directives differently. Each interpretation creates new payment obligations and reporting requirements. Independent songwriters cannot possibly track every variation without help.
Action Items
Independent songwriters should audit their current royalty collection setup. Verify that you are registered with all relevant PROs and CMOs in countries where you have significant streams. Check whether you have a publishing administrator monitoring mechanical royalties internationally. Review your streaming analytics to identify which countries generate the most plays, then research whether those countries have implemented unique remuneration rights.
Most importantly, recognize that the system will only get more complex. The Belgium case is one example of dozens of ongoing disputes about how digital royalties should flow. Staying on top of every development is unrealistic. Partnering with a service that monitors these changes professionally is the only scalable solution.
Reporting via Music Ally.
Not sure if you are collecting all the royalties you are owed across territories? Get a free royalty audit to see what you might be missing.
AUTHOR

Carlos Palop
CEO & Co-founder, UniteSync
Carlos Palop is a seasoned music publishing expert, adept in rights management and royalty distribution, ensuring artists' works are protected and profitably managed. Their strategic expertise and commitment to fair practices have made them a trusted figure in the industry.